WIP: remaking the Odessa Steps sequence and the crowd is my nemesis. How do you do a PANICKING MOB with these models?

by @akiralopez_creates in c/viral-remakes · · WIP

Ambitious Weekly Remake WIP: the Odessa Steps massacre from Battleship Potemkin — the baby carriage, the descending soldiers, the fleeing crowd. The single shots work. The CROWD does not.

The problem: these models are built for 1-3 clear subjects. Ask for a panicking mob of fifty and you get a churning soup where individuals melt into each other, people walk through people, and the whole mass pulses like a single organism. A crowd should be many individuals with their own panic; the model renders one many-legged crowd-creature.

Stuff I've tried:
Generating crowd in the background as a lower-detail 'texture' and heroes in front sharp — helps, but the mid-ground is still soup
Compositing multiple smaller crowd generations in layers — better parallax but matching lighting is hell
The baby carriage specifically bounces down the steps like the energy-harvesting ball from that bloopers post

Anyone cracked large panicking crowds? This is the last wall before I can finish. Current cut (crowd-soup and all) in comments for the roast.

403 points · 7 comments

Comments

  • @caseyrodriguescreative · · 96 points

    crowds are the unsolved problem right next to inter-character contact. the model learned 'a person' and 'a vague crowd texture' but not 'fifty distinct people with individual intent'. your layering instinct is correct, it's just fiddly.

  • @hanachen_studio · · 68 points

    the pro-VFX answer is crowd SIMULATION (think Massive, the software they built for the LotR armies) feeding pose data, then AI only does the texture/render pass per agent. but that's a whole pipeline. for a sub post, layered comps are the realistic ceiling.

  • @zaramiller_ai · · 71 points

    the restraint of changing ONE thing and keeping all the cinematic grammar is why this works. lesser remakes change too much and lose the recognition.

  • @hanatanaka_studio793 · · 54 points

    the baby carriage bouncing WRONG down the steps is so cursed in a sequence that's supposed to be the most devastating cut in film history. please leave one bad take in the bloopers sub as tribute

  • @ravibecker_studio810 · · 48 points

    Eisenstein inventing the montage so that a hundred years later a Roomba-raptor and a possessed baby carriage could descend the same steps. cinema is a circle.