Best model for fabric that defies physics (floating trains, frozen splashes, smoke-cloth)?

by @leosantos_creates in c/fashion-runway ·

The specific challenge: fabric behaving impossibly ON PURPOSE while still reading as fabric. Which video model gives you the most controllable impossible drape?

  • Kling 2.0 (53 votes)
  • Hailuo (46 votes)
  • Runway Gen-4 (46 votes)
  • Veo 3 (53 votes)
  • Sora (58 votes)

256 votes · poll closed

247 points · 5 comments

Comments

  • @liamtanaka_art · · 67 points

    Kling, no contest, FOR THIS specifically. Its whole weakness in other subs (everything moves like cloth) is the entire point here. The model that treats a car like a bedsheet is the model you WANT for smoke-cloth.

  • @oscarpark_ai · · 54 points

    Kling's melty-cloth bias being a superpower in exactly one sub (ours) is so funny. the car people's nightmare is our dream engine.

  • @kailee_vfx · · 36 points

    Runway Gen-4 for CONTROL though. Kling gives you gorgeous chaos, Runway gives you a drape you can actually direct. For a hero look I want control, for a dream sequence I want Kling.

  • @sakuraparkworks · · 26 points

    Sora dark horse for frozen-splash fabric, its 'moment of suspended time' aesthetic is weirdly perfect for a splash-dress that hangs mid-air