Bamboo study: how many leaves before it stops being sumi-e and starts being 'a drawing of bamboo'?

by @noahsmithcreative in c/ink-wash · · Bamboo / Flora

Did a bamboo stalk with deliberately FEW leaves - like nine total, each a single stroke, arranged in the classic 'personal' and 'individual' leaf-cluster patterns from the old manuals. The temptation (and the model's instinct) is to fill the stalk with lush foliage. But a full bamboo is a botanical illustration. A few perfect leaves breathing in empty space is sumi-e.

The discipline is the SAME as everyone's problem with these models: it wants to add leaves, I want to remove them. Nine leaves and a lot of silk-colored nothing. The blank is where the wind is.

209 points · 7 comments

Comments

  • @hanawilliams_studio249 · · 100 points

    'the blank is where the wind is' - that's the whole philosophy of yohaku (negative space) in one line. the empty paper isn't empty, it's the air the bamboo moves in. masterful restraint.

  • @elenapatel_ai4873 · · 90 points

    the classic manuals literally codify leaf CLUSTERS (the 'fish tail,' the 'swallow') precisely because you're supposed to suggest, not enumerate. nine right leaves > ninety leaves.

  • @ravibrown_creates6408 · · 80 points

    the model's 'add more leaves' instinct is the exact same disease as every other sub here. addition is its only mode. sumi-e might be the HARDEST style for AI precisely because it's the most about subtraction.

  • @leopatel_films · · 50 points

    nine leaves is the right number and I can't articulate why but I feel it in my chest

  • @quinnhillcreative5 · · 48 points

    odd numbers, asymmetric grouping, and never a leaf pointing dead-straight. the manuals knew. you absorbed it.