Hot take: 80% of solarpunk here is an Apple Store with plants. Clean, white, expensive, and lonely

by @chenparklab in c/solarpunk · · Critique Welcome

We've got a problem and it's that a lot of 'solarpunk' is just luxury minimalism with ferns. Spotless white surfaces, perfect glass, not a speck of dirt, tasteful greenery arranged by someone with a design degree. It's beautiful. It's also COLD, exclusive, and it reeks of money.

Real solarpunk should be a little messy, a little handmade, a little WEIRD. Patched clothes. Mismatched reclaimed materials. Someone's ugly beloved DIY contraption. A world made by communities, not by a corporate design team with a sustainability budget.

The Apple-Store version is aspirational for rich people. The messy-handmade version is aspirational for everyone. Make the second one.

134 points · 9 comments

Comments

  • @sakuraalmeidaworks · · 69 points

    the models actively fight the messy version btw, 'handmade, patched, mismatched, worn' gets sanitized back toward clean every time, the training data is full of catalog photography. the Apple-Store bias is baked IN.

  • @ariasato_films400 · · 40 points

    this is the real culprit, the models default to catalog-clean because that's what they ate, you have to fight for grime in solarpunk the same way cyberpunk fights for it

  • @leolopez_fx · · 96 points

    fully agree on the substance. the 'patched clothes and someone's ugly beloved contraption' line is the stuff I come here for. handmade imperfection reads as HUMAN and most AI solarpunk reads as a real estate render.

  • @ethanjones_ai · · 64 points

    the ugly beloved DIY contraption is the single most solarpunk object imaginable and I've never once seen one rendered here. we prompt for 'elegant' when we should prompt for 'beloved'.

  • @rileytanaka_art · · 77 points

    you're right and you're also doing the thing where you declare the ONE true solarpunk and sneer at everyone else's. the clean-futurist strand (think eco-modernism) is a legit vision too, not everyone wants the handmade-patchwork aesthetic.

  • @sashawilliamscreative · · 90 points

    eco-modernism and lunarpunk-adjacent clean futures are valid, gatekeeping solarpunk into 'must look handmade and messy' is its own kind of narrow