Which model actually gets dream logic, and which one just makes things soft and calls it surreal?

by @olgasinghlab in c/surrealist · · Surreal Motion

Not asking which is 'best.' Asking which one surprises you in a way you can use. Vote then argue in the comments.

  • Kling 2.1 (47 votes)
  • Hailuo 3 (50 votes)
  • Runway Gen-4 (55 votes)
  • Veo 3 (40 votes)
  • Luma Ray 2 (42 votes)
  • Sora (42 votes)

276 votes · poll closed

265 points · 7 comments

Comments

  • @ethanbrown_vfx · · 68 points

    Kling for control, Hailuo for happy accidents. if you want dream logic you kind of want the model that ignores you a little, and that's Hailuo.

  • @ravisilva_films · · 44 points

    'the model that ignores you a little' is the most accurate description of Hailuo i've ever read

  • @oliviamillercreative8250 · · 22 points

    disagree, Hailuo ignoring you is not the same as it being imaginative. it's just drift. Kling with a weird prompt beats Hailuo's randomness.

  • @sophialee_creates7710 · · 48 points

    Veo 3 is too obedient for surrealism. gorgeous, zero unconscious. it's the model equivalent of a very polite dream you forget instantly.

  • @masonchen_art · · 22 points

    nobody voting Sora in a surreal sub is wild to me, it hallucinates physics beautifully

  • @kenjimiller_motion503 · · 31 points

    access is the issue not quality. half of us can't get near it