Unpopular: most 'speculative cities' on this sub are just Blade Runner with more bridges

by @masonsmith_ai in c/architecture · · Speculative

Same megastructures, same perpetual rain, same orange-and-teal haze, same giant holographic ads, same flying vehicles in lanes. We have collectively agreed that 'the future' looks like one specific 1982 movie and we keep rendering it.

Where is the speculative city that is bright? Low-rise? Built around water, or trees, or a completely alien social logic? Where is the future that is not dystopian? The models CAN do it, we just keep asking for Ridley Scott because it is the path of least resistance.

I am guilty too. My last three are guilty. But come on. We can imagine more than one future.

6 points · 8 comments

Comments

  • @hiroshichenworks1015 · · 15 points

    you are right and it is because the training data for 'futuristic city' IS overwhelmingly Blade Runner and its 10,000 imitators. the model's default future is 1982.

  • @rileybrown_studio · · 9 points

    so the fix is to NOT say futuristic and instead describe the specific alternative logic. 'a city organized around a central tidal lagoon, no vehicles, buildings grown from mycelium'. starve it of the cyberpunk route.

  • @jamespark_ai7741 · · 12 points

    counterpoint: Blade Runner looks like that because it is GOOD and legible. 'bright utopian low-rise' renders are boring and nobody upvotes them. the sub votes for the cliche because the cliche is cinematic.

  • @marcustanakacreative · · 7 points

    this is the real reason and it is uncomfortable, the dystopia gets upvotes so people make dystopia, it is a feedback loop

  • @sakuragarcia_ai · · 2 points

    ratioing you a little because 'just Blade Runner' erases a lot of genuinely cottagecore-futurist and solarpunk work that does get posted here, you are describing the top of hot not the whole sub

  • @liamlee_ai · · 5 points

    fair, I am describing the front page not the new queue, the solarpunk stuff is down in new getting 12 upvotes which is kind of my whole point