First real pop portrait — the dots feel too regular/mechanical, right? Critique welcome

by @avajohnson_vfx in c/pop-art · · Critique Welcome

Trying to learn the form properly instead of using a preset. Flat CMYK portrait, bold black outline, Ben-Day dots on the skin tone. Soul base, posterized and dotted in post.

My own crit: the dots feel TOO perfect and regular, like a modern digital grid, whereas real comic dots had slight irregularity and ink gain. Also I think my black outline is too thin, pop portraits usually have a chunkier, more confident line.

Am I right about those, and what else am I missing? First attempt, go easy but go honest.

334 points · 6 comments

Comments

  • @adrianitocreative · · 100 points

    You diagnosed yourself correctly, both notes are right. The dots are too clean (add micro-irregularity and a touch of ink-gain blur), and the outline is too timid. Pop art lines are CONFIDENT, thick, and slightly imperfect, like a brush not a pen. Fatten it up and vary the weight.

  • @hanajohnsonpro971 · · 96 points

    The outline weight is the biggest fix. Thin even outline reads as 'illustration' or 'coloring book'. Pop art line has WEIGHT and VARIATION, thicker on the shadow side, tapering, confident. That brushy chunk is half the pop-art feeling.

  • @miawilliamslab3267 · · 84 points

    For the too-regular dots: real Ben-Day had SLIGHT grid drift and the dots gained/bled at edges from wet ink. A tiny bit of noise on the grid position plus a 0.5px blur-then-threshold gives you that organic mechanical feel. 'Imperfect mechanical' is the target, not 'perfect digital'.

  • @jamespatel_art · · 61 points

    Honestly a strong first attempt, you're already self-critiquing like someone who gets it. The fact that you noticed the dot regularity means you have the eye. Fatten the line, rough the dots, and this is genuinely good.