Which model handles PURE color best (no detail creeping in)?

by @sakuratanakacreative in c/abstract-art ·

The abstract struggle: getting flat pure color without the model sneaking in detail, texture, or an implied subject. Which fights you least?

  • Midjourney (low stylize) (80 votes)
  • Soul (83 votes)
  • Seedance / Kling for motion (91 votes)
  • None, I generate loose and refine in post (106 votes)

360 votes · poll closed

353 points · 4 comments

Comments

  • @irislee_fx · · 100 points

    'None, I refine in post' and it's not even close for serious color work. EVERY model is compulsively driven to add detail, texture, and implied form because it's trained on photos of THINGS, not on pure color. Asking any of them for 'pure color, no detail' is asking against their entire nature. You generate a rough color relationship and then you STRIP the detail back out in post. The purity is subtractive, done by you.

  • @yunarodrigues_creates · · 82 points

    The model physically cannot resist adding 'interest', a texture here, a suggestion of form there, because its training says images have CONTENT. Pure color is anti-content. You're always going to be removing the model's helpful additions. The post-process strip-down is mandatory for anyone doing real color-field work.

  • @hiroshimiller1555 · · 58 points

    The detail-creep is worst in the areas the model thinks are 'empty', it fills voids with faint texture because it has a prior against flatness. Big flat fields are exactly where it misbehaves most. Ironically the simpler the color field you want, the harder the model fights you. Simplicity is the hardest ask.

  • @priyaflores_films · · 67 points

    Midjourney at stylize 0 gets closest to flat pure color natively, high stylize adds painterly detail which is the enemy here. But 'closest' still isn't 'pure'. There's always SOME creeping texture. Model choice reduces the post-work but doesn't eliminate it.