Same OC across 12 shots with NO character LoRA - IP-Adapter + reference-sheet trick (consistency test)

by @sakuragarcia_films in c/anime-lab · · Consistency Test

Lab Result. Goal: keep one original character identical across 12 different poses/angles/expressions without training a LoRA (because training a LoRA for every OC is slow and I am impatient).

Method: (1) Generate a clean character REFERENCE SHEET first - front, 3/4, side, with a couple expressions, all in one image, locked down and perfect. (2) Feed that sheet into IP-Adapter (FaceID + a general IP-Adapter at ~0.6) as the identity anchor for every subsequent shot. (3) Keep a short consistent 'character token' phrase in every prompt ('silver bob, red eyes, scar over left brow, black uniform').

Result: 9 of 12 shots are convincingly the same person. The 3 failures were extreme angles (full back, extreme low angle) where IP-Adapter loses the face anchor. For those I hand-fix or re-roll.

Conclusion: for a one-off project, reference-sheet + IP-Adapter beats training a LoRA on time-to-result. For a long series, still train the LoRA. Sheet in comments.

633 points · 8 comments

Comments

  • @leorodriguez735 · · 84 points

    Generating a locked reference SHEET first and using IT as the IP-Adapter source (instead of one hero image) is the key detail everyone misses. One image gives the adapter one angle to cling to. A SHEET gives it the character in the round. 9/12 with no LoRA is excellent.

  • @avasilva_creates · · 61 points

    OP - the sheet is doing what a LoRA's training set does, just at inference time instead of training time. You are giving IP-Adapter multiple views to triangulate the identity from. One hero image = it only knows the front.

  • @chenmartinez_creates · · 52 points

    The honest 9/12 with named failure cases is why this is a good Lab Result and not a flex. The 'extreme angles break the face anchor' finding is genuinely useful - it tells me WHEN to reach for the LoRA instead.

  • @hanapark_studio · · 38 points

    OP - exactly, the failures ARE the result. Now you know: reference-sheet method for normal angles, LoRA for a project with a lot of extreme/back shots. Pick the tool by the shot list.

  • @takeshiverma_films · · 41 points

    scar-over-left-brow in the token phrase is a pro move, a specific asymmetric landmark gives the model an anchor way more than 'red eyes' which it will put on anyone

  • @noahmartinezcreative · · 33 points

    OP - asymmetric specific landmarks (a scar, a single earring, a streak of different-colored hair) are consistency GOLD, they are hard to hallucinate wrong and easy to check