Flat shading vs smooth(ish) shading on low-poly: where do you actually draw the line?

by @emmasanchez_studio570 in c/low-poly ·

The classic schism. Hard flat facets everywhere, or a little smoothing on the organic stuff (animals, terrain) while keeping props sharp? Vote your religion.

  • Flat facets on EVERYTHING, no exceptions (18 votes)
  • Flat props, smoothed organics (24 votes)
  • Smooth normals + hard edges only where it counts (13 votes)
  • Vertex colors decide it, not normals (19 votes)

74 votes · poll closed

23 points · 8 comments

Comments

  • @hanakim_vfx · · 65 points

    vertex colors deciding it is the galaxy-brain answer. the shading model matters less than the color blocking. a flat fox with great vertex colors beats a perfectly-normaled one.

  • @yukismithworks5723 · · 63 points

    flat props + smoothed organics is the pragmatic middle and it's what every actual low-poly MOBILE GAME shipped, for the record. the purists can argue, the shipped games already answered this years ago.

  • @kailee_studio · · 40 points

    'the shipped games already answered this' is the kind of pragmatism that ends holy wars and I respect it

  • @emmabrown · · 78 points

    Flat on everything or it's not low-poly, it's just 'low detail.' The facet IS the style. A smoothed low-poly fox is just a bad regular fox.

  • @lunamartinez_art · · 92 points

    hard disagree, a little smoothing on a deer's body with flat-shaded antlers is peak. the contrast of soft form + hard detail is gorgeous.