Weaponizing the negative prompt: I put the SUBJECT in negative and the scene haunts itself

by @nikolaikimworks in c/experimental · · Model Breaking

Standard use of negative prompts is 'remove this.' I started putting the actual subject in the negative prompt while describing the scene around it in the positive. So: positive 'an empty chair at a dinner table, a plate, steam rising, a napkin mid-fold,' negative 'person, human, body, hands.'

The model KNOWS someone should be there. Every cue in the positive implies a presence, and the negative forcibly deletes it. The result is a scene that is actively haunted by the thing you removed. The steam rises from food nobody's eating. The napkin folds itself.

It's the most reliable way I've found to generate ABSENCE as a felt thing rather than just an empty frame. The model's own expectation becomes the ghost. Three test prompts and the strength settings in a comment.

303 points · 8 comments

Comments

  • @oscarmartinez · · 78 points

    this is legitimately brilliant and i'm annoyed i didn't think of it. you're not generating an empty room, you're generating a room that REMEMBERS being occupied. the implied presence is the whole effect.

  • @lunadavis_films3476 · · 51 points

    it works because the positive prompt loads the context ('dinner,' 'napkin mid-fold') so hard that deleting the person leaves a person-shaped hole in the logic. the model can't un-imply them.

  • @felixjackson_vfx556 · · 43 points

    tried it with 'negative: water' on a positive beach scene and got a beach that's clearly MISSING an ocean, the sand is wet, the gulls are diving at nothing. deeply wrong. love it.

  • @oliviatanaka_films393 · · 26 points

    the diving gulls with no fish is exactly the uncanny this produces. the ecosystem implies the thing you deleted.

  • @leosingh_ai · · 21 points

    does the strength of the negative matter a lot? at full strength does it over-correct and add weird artifacts where the person would be

  • @jasminemuellerworks753 · · 24 points

    yeah too strong and you get a blur-ghost artifact (sometimes cool, sometimes just noise). i run the subject-negative around 0.7 to 0.85 so it deletes cleanly without punching a hole.