I used Retro Diffusion as a base and cleaned it to a real grid in Aseprite. Here's the before/after and exactly what I fixed.

by @masontanaka268 in c/pixel-art · · WIP

Posting this as a workflow transparency thing because the Peace Treaty says tag it, and because the CLEANUP is where the actual pixel art happens.

The AI base (Retro Diffusion): looked like pixel art at a glance. Zoomed in, it was a disaster — pixels were 1.3 'real' pixels wide in places, anti-aliasing fuzz on every edge, the palette had 40+ near-duplicate colors, and the pixel grid drifted diagonally across the image (classic AI tell).

What cleanup actually involved:
Downscaled to lock a true 1x grid, nearest-neighbor, then fixed every pixel that landed between cells by hand
Palette-reduced from 40ish to 12, choosing the 12 deliberately (this is a real art decision the AI did not make)
Redrew every edge to kill the anti-aliasing — about 60% of the final pixels got hand-touched
Fixed the drifting grid by redrawing whole regions aligned to the true grid

Honest conclusion: the AI gave me a composition and a color MOOD in 10 seconds. But 'cleaning it' was 4 hours and by the end I'd hand-placed most of the pixels anyway. It's a fancy reference generator, not a pixel art generator. Anyone saying 'AI does pixel art now' has never zoomed in. Before/after in comments, zoom in and judge.

890 points · 8 comments

Comments

  • @oscarjohnsonlab · · 66 points

    4 hours of cleanup for a 10-second generation is a genuinely useful data point for anyone thinking the AI route is a shortcut. it moves the labor, it doesn't remove it. if you want a clean grid, someone's placing those pixels, and that someone is you.

  • @chenverma_films · · 93 points

    the downvotes on this post are wild to me. you were TRANSPARENT, you did the actual work, and you concluded the AI barely helped. this is the most pro-craft AI post possible and people are mad it exists at all. if cleaning to a real grid by hand isn't pixel art I don't know what is.

  • @felixbecker_studio · · 80 points

    some people see 'Retro Diffusion' in the title and downvote before reading. they'd have upvoted the identical final piece if you hadn't disclosed. the Peace Treaty asks for honesty and honesty costs karma. kind of proves the disclosure matters though.

  • @sophiadaviscreative · · 91 points

    'it's a fancy reference generator, not a pixel art generator' is the most honest take on AI pixel art I've seen and it should end half the arguments here. the model gives you a mood board. YOU do the pixel art. the moment you zoom in the illusion dies.

  • @novasanchez_films455 · · 97 points

    the drifting diagonal grid is the #1 AI tell and it's EVERYWHERE once you learn to see it. real pixel art has a rigid grid because it was made ON a grid. AI 'pixel art' has a grid that slowly slides because the model is faking the LOOK of pixels, not working in pixels. it never had a grid to begin with.