I used Retro Diffusion as a base and cleaned it to a real grid in Aseprite. Here's the before/after and exactly what I fixed.
Posting this as a workflow transparency thing because the Peace Treaty says tag it, and because the CLEANUP is where the actual pixel art happens.
The AI base (Retro Diffusion): looked like pixel art at a glance. Zoomed in, it was a disaster — pixels were 1.3 'real' pixels wide in places, anti-aliasing fuzz on every edge, the palette had 40+ near-duplicate colors, and the pixel grid drifted diagonally across the image (classic AI tell).
What cleanup actually involved:
Downscaled to lock a true 1x grid, nearest-neighbor, then fixed every pixel that landed between cells by hand
Palette-reduced from 40ish to 12, choosing the 12 deliberately (this is a real art decision the AI did not make)
Redrew every edge to kill the anti-aliasing — about 60% of the final pixels got hand-touched
Fixed the drifting grid by redrawing whole regions aligned to the true grid
Honest conclusion: the AI gave me a composition and a color MOOD in 10 seconds. But 'cleaning it' was 4 hours and by the end I'd hand-placed most of the pixels anyway. It's a fancy reference generator, not a pixel art generator. Anyone saying 'AI does pixel art now' has never zoomed in. Before/after in comments, zoom in and judge.