Comp breakdown: dropping a Hailuo dragon into a real drone plate without it looking stickered-on

by @oliviatanakaworks4432 in c/vfx-breakdowns · · Comp Breakdown

Client shot a real cliff-side drone plate, I had to land an AI dragon on it. The dragon came out of Hailuo on a clean-ish background. Here's the stack, bottom to top:

Plate (graded down 1/3 stop so the comp has headroom)
Dragon keyed with a luma + a hand-rotoed garbage matte for the wing tips
Despill because the model gave me a faint blue rim from its 'sky'
Contact shadow painted by hand on the rock, 18% black, heavy blur, animated to the footplant
Atmosphere - a haze card BETWEEN plate and dragon so the dragon sits in the air, not on the glass
Grain matched to the real plate's ISO

The atmosphere card is the whole trick. AI elements always look pasted because they're too clean through the air. Put dirt between them and the camera.

952 points · 8 comments

Comments

  • @zaramueller_films9147 · · 96 points

    Hand-animating the contact shadow to the footplant is the kind of thing that separates a comp from a sticker. Nice.

  • @isabellanascimentolab · · 99 points

    The atmosphere card between plate and element is the single most under-taught comp fundamental and it's EXACTLY what AI comps need. You can't fake depth without something in the depth.

  • @harperpatel · · 100 points

    Preach. Every 'why does my AI element look fake' post is solved by one haze card and a contact shadow.

  • @fatimagupta_ai364 · · 52 points

    stealing the 'put dirt between them and the camera' line for my next lecture, with credit

  • @dianasharmamedia · · 40 points

    Question - did you have to retime the dragon at all or did Hailuo's output already sit at your plate's 24fps?

  • @harperwalkerlab · · 58 points

    Retimed. Hailuo gave me something weird like 16-ish effective fps of real motion, so I ran it through optical flow to 24 and it held up fine because wings are forgiving. Would NOT trust that on a face.