The catchlight is 80% of whether a portrait feels alive. Here's the cheat sheet.

by @nikolaisilva_studio in c/portrait-studio · · Lighting Study

After way too many dead-eyed renders, the single highest-leverage fix is the catchlight (the reflection of the light source in the eye).

Rules I've landed on:

Shape matters. A soft box gives a clean rectangle. A ring light gives a donut (and screams 'influencer'). A window gives a soft rectangle with a gradient. Prompt the source shape, not 'catchlight'.
Position: 10 or 2 o'clock, upper iris. Dead-center catchlight = doll. Lower = creepy. Upper-off-center = alive.
Asymmetry. The two eyes should NOT have identical catchlights. Different size, slightly different position. Perfect symmetry is the #1 AI tell.
One dominant, maybe one tiny fill. Three catchlights = you have a studio-lighting problem and it looks busy.

Soul handles catchlights better than most out of the box but still loves perfect symmetry, so I inpaint one eye's specular slightly off every time.

1,099 points · 10 comments

Comments

  • @fatimayoung_films922 · · 97 points

    The asymmetry point is THE one. I zoom into every portrait now and if the two catchlights are identical twins I know it's an unretouched gen.

  • @rileycosta_films2678 · · 54 points

    Same. It's become my single fastest 'is this AI' check, faster than hands now.

  • @ravimueller_vfx · · 61 points

    saving this and printing it out, 'upper iris, 10 or 2 o'clock, asymmetric' is going above my monitor

  • @sashachopra · · 98 points

    'A ring light gives a donut and screams influencer' — I have never been so attacked by accurate information.

  • @noahjohnsonworks · · 87 points

    the donut catchlight is the 2020s equivalent of a bad 2010s HDR photo. instantly dates the image.

  • @jamessilva2074 · · 43 points

    Soul vs Flux for catchlights — Soul wins on realism but Flux lets me control the source shape better with prompt. Anyone found a model that does both?

  • @avamiller_studio · · 39 points

    Honestly I gen in Flux for control then do a Soul img2img pass at low denoise just to get the eye realism. Frankenstein pipeline but the eyes come alive.