Midjourney v7 vs Flux for a painterly oil look — which are you actually reaching for?

by @kaichen_creates in c/oil-painting ·

Not 'which is better in general'. Which do you open when the goal is a convincing oil painting specifically.

  • Midjourney v7 (smoother, glaze-friendly) (81 votes)
  • Flux dev (keeps more texture/knife work) (63 votes)
  • SDXL + a good oil LoRA (77 votes)
  • I paint the base elsewhere, model is just a finisher (69 votes)
  • Still hunting, none nail it (66 votes)

356 votes · poll closed

348 points · 4 comments

Comments

  • @irinacosta_creates741 · · 99 points

    Flux for impasto, MJ for glazed Rembrandt stuff. They fail in opposite directions. Flux can't stop texturing, MJ can't stop smoothing.

  • @sophiasmith_ai · · 47 points

    Perfectly put. I literally pick based on whether the subject is a 1-hour alla prima or a 6-week glazed portrait.

  • @hiroshicosta_art · · 53 points

    voted 'none nail it' out of spite and principle

  • @zarabrown_films6214 · · 64 points

    SDXL + a hand-trained LoRA on actual museum scans still beats both for me, it's just more work. The base models are trained on too much digital-painting slop.