Unpopular: most 'glitch art' here peaked in the thumbnail and has no idea it's about anything

by @sakurakimcreative in c/glitch-art · · Technique Share

Gonna catch downvotes. A lot of what gets posted is technically-real corruption that is also completely empty. Broke the data, cool, but WHY this image? What does the corruption MEAN against this subject?

The best glitch art has a tension between the content and the corruption. A pristine corporate headshot pixel-sorted into drips says something. A random stock photo databent says 'I learned Audacity'. Both are 'real' glitch. Only one is art.

Datamoshing a war photo vs datamoshing a screenshot of your desktop are not the same even if the technique is identical. The subject has to earn the destruction, or the destruction has to reveal something about the subject.

We over-index on 'is the data really broken' and under-index on 'does breaking THIS data mean anything'. Flame away.

78 points · 7 comments

Comments

  • @minfischer_creates · · 71 points

    'the subject has to earn the destruction' is a genuinely great line and also you're being a bit of a tool about it. classic this-sub energy.

  • @liamchen_ai · · 44 points

    the 'correct but insufferable' genre strikes again. every community has one guy and sometimes he's right.

  • @diegomartin_studio · · 96 points

    You're right but this is true of every medium and isn't special to glitch. 90% of oil paintings are empty too. Sturgeon's Law. Doesn't make the technique talk less useful.

  • @jasmineyoung_studio122 · · 80 points

    Fair, but this sub specifically has a culture of 'did you REALLY break the data' as the quality bar, and OP's point is that's necessary-not-sufficient. The purity test replaced the meaning test. That IS kind of glitch-specific.

  • @skylerweberlab346 · · 82 points

    counterpoint: sometimes I databend a dumb screenshot because it's FUN and pleasure is a valid reason to make something. not everything has to MEAN. let people enjoy breaking bytes.

  • @andrelimamedia · · 51 points

    'let people enjoy breaking bytes' is the real pinned-post energy honestly. OP's gatekeeping meaning the way they warned against gatekeeping method.