WIP: impossible goalkeeper save but the ball clips THROUGH his hand, every single time, help

by @nikolaisatomedia in c/sports-highlights · · WIP

The save is gorgeous, a full-extension flying parry on a top-corner rocket, the keeper's a poem in mid-air. Except the ball passes THROUGH his outstretched hand like he's a ghost, every generation, and then deflects away as if it hit something, so you get this cursed moment where the ball clearly phases through solid fingers and then obeys a collision that didn't visibly happen.

It's the classic AI contact problem, the model understands 'ball goes toward hand' and 'ball deflects away' but not the actual MOMENT OF CONTACT, the physical touch where hand meets ball and force transfers. The contact frame is where it all falls apart.

I've tried emphasizing 'palm strikes the ball, fingers deflect it, point of contact' and it helps the deflection angle but the phase-through persists. Anyone solved the contact-moment problem? Because right now my keeper is a very athletic ghost. WIP in comments, admire the dive, ignore the hand passing through a solid object.

174 points · 8 comments

Comments

  • @liammartinez_vfx · · 84 points

    the moment-of-contact problem is the HARDEST thing in AI sports because the model has no physics engine, it knows 'approach' and 'departure' as separate learned motions but the actual collision (the deform, the force transfer, the instant of touch) is a physics EVENT it can't simulate, so it skips it and phases through

  • @victorjohnson · · 64 points

    the fix that works for me: slow WAY down at the contact frame and emphasize DEFORMATION, 'the ball COMPRESSES against the palm, the hand bends back from the impact,' give the model the SQUASH, because contact without squash is what reads as phase-through, the deform IS the proof of contact

  • @jamessinghcreative · · 52 points

    you can also HIDE the contact frame, motion-blur the exact instant of impact so heavily that the eye can't tell the ball phased through, the blur covers the sin, same as hiding a bad frame in the film sub, obscure the moment you can't render

  • @sophiachencreative7438 · · 36 points

    the heavy-motion-blur-on-contact trick is the cheap reliable fix, real high-speed impacts ARE a blur anyway, so blurring the contact frame is both realistic AND it hides the phase-through, you're not cheating, impacts really do blur

  • @zaramuellercreative · · 29 points

    the dive itself is genuinely beautiful, full-extension keeper poetry, once you fix the ghost-hand this is a highlight-reel save, you're one contact-frame away