Does abstract AI art even count as 'yours'?

by @avasmith in c/abstract-art ·

The question that haunts every post here. When the machine generates the forms, where's the authorship? Where do you honestly land?

  • Yes, authorship is in curation & intent (120 votes)
  • Only if you build a system/process (116 votes)
  • No, you're just picking the model's output (102 votes)
  • Wrong question, art was never about 'making' every mark (102 votes)

440 votes · poll closed

400 points · 8 comments

Comments

  • @charlottesharma_fx591 · · 97 points

    'Wrong question' gang. Photographers don't make the light. Collagists don't make the scraps. Conductors don't make the notes. Readymade artists literally bought the object. Authorship has NEVER required making every element, it's about selection, framing, intent, composition. The 'did you make the marks' standard would delete half of modern art, not just AI.

  • @leocosta_films · · 98 points

    Duchamp settled this in 1917 and we're relitigating it because the tool is new and scary. The urinal wasn't 'made' by Duchamp. The authorship was the CHOICE and the CONTEXT. If a signed urinal is art, a curated generative output can be too. The anxiety is about novelty, not a real philosophical gap.

  • @olivialee_vfx9358 · · 88 points

    'Only if you build a system' is my honest position. Typing 'beautiful abstract color field' and picking your favorite of four outputs is CHOOSING, not AUTHORING. But building a feedback loop or a layering process that YOU designed, where the output reflects YOUR system, that's authorship. The generative-process folks earn it. The prompt-and-pick folks are curating, which is lesser (not nothing, but lesser).

  • @andresilvalab · · 61 points

    The 'prompt-and-pick is lesser than system-building' hierarchy is defensible but gatekeep-y. Curation IS a skill and an authorship, ask any editor or any photographer who 'just' pressed a button at the right moment. Building a system is MORE involved, sure, but 'lesser' undersells the eye required to pick the one good output from the noise.

  • @nikolaikimworks · · 75 points

    No, and I say this as someone who MAKES this stuff. Let's be honest with ourselves. The model made the forms. I picked one. I'm a curator, a director maybe, but calling myself the 'artist' of an image whose every actual mark was decided by a neural net feels like a stretch I'm not fully comfortable with. The discomfort is worth sitting with instead of arguing away.

  • @nikolaiwilliams_studio · · 61 points

    Respect for the honesty. The rush to philosophically justify our authorship (Duchamp! photography!) can be a way of avoiding a genuinely unresolved discomfort. Maybe it's okay that it's unresolved. Maybe 'director' or 'curator' is a more honest title than 'artist' for a lot of what we do here, and that's fine, those are real roles too.